News

As the Yankees and Mets prepare to clash in the first leg of the 2025 Subway Series at Yankee Stadium, collectors are getting just as excited as fans in the stands. Both teams are stacked with a mix of seasoned stars and promising young talent—and that means the card market is heating up. Whether you’re a die-hard fan or just looking for the next big investment, the rookie cards tied to this year's top Subway Series players are ones to keep on your radar.

Let’s break down eight players making waves this weekend—and the rookie cards collectors are chasing.

Trent Grisham (Yankees)
Grisham’s defense has always been solid, but his bat has finally caught fire in 2025. He’s slashing .283 with 12 home runs and a .996 OPS, making his underrated rookie card a sleeper hit. His 2020 Topps Chrome RC is a budget-friendly option—raw copies run between $1–$4, while PSA 10 refractors are still very accessible at $12–$20. That window of affordability may not last.

Ben Rice (Yankees)
Quietly becoming a dependable bat and glove at first base, Rice is holding his own with a .254 average, 9 home runs, and a .900 OPS. His 2024 Bowman Chrome Prospects 1st Bowman card is one collectors are starting to pay attention to. Raw versions sell for $8–$12, while PSA 10s are hovering in the $45–$55 range.

Aaron Judge (Yankees)
The face of the Yankees franchise is putting together one of his best seasons yet. With a .412 average, 15 homers, and a staggering 1.279 OPS, Judge’s cards are as hot as his bat. His 2017 Topps Chrome “Catching” RC remains a must-have. Expect to pay $70–$90 raw, and around $220–$250 for a PSA 10.

Cody Bellinger (Yankees)
Now wearing pinstripes, Bellinger’s bat hasn’t fully ignited just yet (.229 AVG, 5 HRs), but collectors haven’t forgotten his former MVP pedigree. His 2017 Topps Chrome RC is still a hot commodity. Raw versions range from $70–$90, with PSA 10s typically going for $220–$250. A resurgence could make this card spike again.

Anthony Volpe (Yankees)
One of the more exciting young players in the Bronx, Volpe is shaping up to have a steady sophomore campaign. His 2020 Bowman Chrome 1st Bowman is a favorite among modern Yankee collectors. Raw copies are a steal at $1–$4, and PSA 10s currently sell for around $30–$35.

Francisco Lindor (Mets)
Lindor has been the heart of the Mets lineup this year, with a .297 average and 9 homers. His 2015 Topps Chrome Update RC is a cornerstone for Mets fans and collectors alike. Prices range from $12–$20 raw and $65–$90 for a PSA 10.

Pete Alonso (Mets)
“The Polar Bear” continues to be a beast at the plate (.311 AVG, 9 HRs, 1.004 OPS). His 2019 Topps Chrome RC is a modern Mets classic. Raw versions are easy on the wallet at $2–$6, while PSA 10s still feel like a deal at $15–$22.

Juan Soto (Mets)
Now wearing Mets blue and armed with the largest contract in MLB history, Soto’s rookie cards have long been hobby favorites. His 2018 Topps Update RC is highly sought-after. Raw versions range from $5–$15, and PSA 10s usually go for $45–$70, but that could jump if he stays hot in New York.

Whether you’re a Yankees fan, a Mets diehard, or a hobbyist looking for smart buys before prices rise, these cards are worthy of attention. With both teams boasting high-octane rosters, this year’s Subway Series isn’t just a battle for bragging rights—it’s a showcase of some of the most collectible talent in the league. If these players continue their current pace, their rookie cards won’t stay this affordable for long.