News

The sports memorabilia world is built on one thing: trust. Trust that the signature on your baseball is authentic, trust that the jersey on your wall was really game-worn, and trust that the person selling it to you isn’t pulling a fast one. But for nearly a decade, Anthony J. Tremayne used that trust as a weapon—and walked away with hundreds of thousands of dollars in the process.

Tremayne, a former resident of California, recently pleaded guilty to a wide-reaching mail fraud scheme that stretched from 2010 to 2019. His specialty? Selling fake autographed memorabilia—complete with forged certificates of authenticity and slick online listings that could fool even seasoned collectors.

His scam wasn’t just about scribbling fake signatures on basketballs and calling it a day. Tremayne went all in. He sold items that looked like they'd come straight from the lockers of sports legends: replica Stanley Cups, autographed boxing gloves, Hall of Fame jackets. He backed them with realistic documentation, often mimicking the format and logos of legitimate third-party authenticators. To the untrained eye—and even some trained ones—these items looked completely legit.

According to investigators, he raked in around $250,000 from unsuspecting buyers. But they believe that if his plan had gone unchecked, it could have ballooned to over half a million in fake merchandise.

The operation finally unraveled thanks to an undercover FBI agent who posed as a buyer. In 2019, the agent purchased a photo supposedly signed by cast members of Keeping Up with the Kardashians for $200. That seemingly small transaction was a key piece of evidence in a much larger investigation. Though Tremayne faced multiple potential charges, he ultimately pleaded guilty to a single count.

His sentencing is scheduled for August 2025, and he could be facing up to 20 years in prison.

For the collecting community, this case goes far beyond one man's con. It’s a wake-up call. The modern memorabilia market has grown rapidly, and with it, so has the opportunity for fraud. Sophisticated forgeries, well-designed fake certificates, and professional-looking websites blur the line between real and fake in ways that make even veteran hobbyists second-guess themselves.

This scandal also highlights a hard truth: enthusiasm can sometimes override skepticism. When a collector spots a dream item at a too-good-to-be-true price, excitement often drowns out caution. That’s what scammers like Tremayne count on.

So where does that leave collectors today? Vigilance is more important than ever. Stick with reputable auction houses and dealers with a track record of integrity. When buying from independent sellers, insist on third-party verification from top-tier authentication companies. And if something feels off—even just slightly—it’s okay to walk away.

Tremayne’s scheme may be over, but others will try to fill the void. Scandals like this don’t just hurt wallets—they damage the confidence and joy that drive the entire collecting community. The best way forward is with a sharper eye and a slower trigger finger.